Critical Reading:
Critical reading is very different from simply reading a text. Kurland (2000) stated that critical reading should focus on what and how the information is written. A critical reader must understand what is actually going on, not just read over the words. There were three key points that he noted on his website:
“What the text:
- Does-Description
- Says- restatement
- Means- interpretation” (Kurland, 2000).
Knott stated the same type of outlook on critical reading. It is not just facts; it is what information is being presented (Knott). Knott also gave some great tips to critical reading. To start out reading the beginning and end of articles aids in getting an idea of where to start. When using a quotation, continue on with more information not just stopping with the quote itself (Knott). Lastly, Knott suggested to read like you listen. In other words learn from what you are reading not just taking bits and pieces out.
What I found most helpful about these two articles is that you need to look past the facts and focus more on what the author is trying to tell me as the reader. I never thought of doing that because it is a lot easier to look at a document and just pick out facts and statistics but I really am not learning anything. Also I found the 3 points from the article I found useful, “What the text says, does, and means” (Kurland, 2000) that right there helped me to really grasp critical reading.
Importance of an Audience
Flower suggests that you should know your audiences knowledge, attitude, and needs. To understand their attitude, you have to help them understand what you mean and what you’re trying to say, especially if they do not know your same knowledge (Flower). In regards to their needs, you should take what you know and teach it to your reader in a way that they can comprehend or relate to. In other words, be their teacher! (Flower).
WordsWork Consulting stated that you should “know who you are writing for.” Many Americans are not strong readers and have trouble understanding concepts, so you must write your paper in an easy-to-read format in order to help them understand (WordsWork). How can you do this? Use common vocabulary that they can understand, to do this you must know your readers. There are also online programs that can test your writing to find the grade level that you write in. Unfortunately these sites are not very reliable (WordsWork).
Both of these sites basically said to know who you are writing for. This is a very important part of your paper because if you need to keep the attention of your readers. The concept of knowing there needs was helpful to read about from Linda Flower. This excerpt really put it into perspective for me, “If you ask a friend majoring in biology how to keep your fish tank from clouding, you don’t want to hear a textbook recitation on the life processes of algae. You except a friend to adapt his or her knowledge and tell you exactly how to solve your problem” (Flowers). That makes perfect sense. Nobody wants to hear lengthy words and explanations of something, keeping it short and to the point is what readers can comprehend.
Flower, Linda. “Writing for an Audience.” Language Awareness: Readings for College Writers. Ed. by Paul Eschholz,
Alfred Rosa, and Virginia Clark. 8th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2000: 139-141.
Knott, Deborah. Critical Reading Towards Critical Writing. Retrieved September 15, 2009, from University of Toronto,
New College Writing Centre Web site: http://www.writing.utoronto.ca/advice/reading-and-researching/critical-reading
Kurland, Daniel J. (2000). What is Critical Reading? Retrieved September 15, 2009,
http://www.criticalreading.com/critical_reading.htm
WordsWork Consulting, Inc. The Importance of Audience. Retrieved September 15, 2009,
http://wordswork.com/tips/audience.html